Welcome to Stacked Sandwich Shop
Stacked Sandwich Shop, located in Forest Hills, NY, offers a variety of delicious sandwiches and salads, with options for customization. The staff is known for being friendly and accommodating, providing excellent service. The menu is diverse, catering to both meat-eaters and vegans alike. Customers rave about the generous portions and unique flavor combinations, such as the Vegan Muffaletta and The Devil sandwich. Stacked Sandwich Shop is a must-visit for sandwich lovers looking for a filling and satisfying meal. Don't miss out on trying their signature sandwiches and salads for a truly satisfying dining experience.
- 68-60 Austin St, Forest Hills, NY 11375, United States68-60 Austin St, Forest Hills, NY 11375, United States Hotline: +1 845-558-3535
Welcome to Stacked Sandwich Shop, located in Forest Hills, NY, a hidden gem in the world of sandwiches and salads. This casual eatery offers a variety of options for both meat-lovers and vegans, ensuring there is something for everyone. The menu boasts build-your-own options, signature sandwiches like the Italian Hottie and Stacked OG, and delicious salads like the chickpea salad.
Customer reviews rave about the friendly staff, generous portion sizes, and speedy service. The sandwiches are described as "amazing" and "huge," with unique flavor combinations that will leave your taste buds wanting more. Vegan options are plentiful, making it a great spot for those with dietary restrictions.
One standout feature of Stacked Sandwich Shop is their commitment to quality ingredients and attention to detail in every dish. From the crunchy bread to the fresh veggies and flavorful sauces, each bite is a culinary delight.
If you're in the mood for a satisfying sandwich or salad, Stacked Sandwich Shop is the place to be. Whether you dine in, order for delivery, or grab takeout, you're sure to have a memorable dining experience at this cozy sub shop.

It's just one of those places you want to keep for yourself but know you need to share it. Stacked offers a great selection of sandwiches and salads along with build your own options. The staff is super friendly and accommodating if you would like suggestions or substitutions they are happy to help. Cute sub shop feel but heads up: pick-up only, no spot to eat.

Love the food and it always comes out great! The service is excellent! And love the cute vibe the shop gives when you walk in. Very unique and the menu board has alot to choose from.

An easy walk from my house. I know places for Italian sandwiches I will travel for but this is not one but it if you are in the neighborhood they are reliably good and the sandwiches are huge, at least two meals. I have had several options from their menu over the last few years, and all are good. We like the Vegan Muffaletta and The Devil best. Their muffins and bagels are not good, so I would walk an extra few blocks to Forest Hills Bagel or Gotta Getta Bagel or for muffins LaBoulangerie or Red Pipes and leave these.

I ordered thru UberEats. I got the Italian Hottie (January specialty sandwich) and some chips. Arrived quickly and well packaged. It was sooooo good. I can't believe it took me so long to try this spot and I can't wait to try other things.

As someone who doesn't eat much meat, it's surprising how much I like Stacked. First, the staff here is great. Everyone is has been super friendly every time I've gone. Sandwich-wise, I like their salads. I didn't know chickpea salad was a thing until I had it here, and I love it. Their egg salad is also pretty good, too. I also really like their overnight oats. The PBJ oats are great, and the apple-cinnamon ones run a close second. I'll also add, while I haven't tried them, my husband has ordered actual heroes from them before. They are literally "stacked" and he thoroughly enjoys them. While it's a little off the beaten path of Forest Hills village (Austin and Yellowstone), it's definitely a great spot to check-out if you're in the mood for a sandwich.

I've gotten the chickpea salad sandwich a several times (delicious! 5/5) and the unreal corned beef sandwich (2/5 wasn't for me). My partner has tried a couple sandwiches (I forget which) but has been very happy with all of them. Kinda pricey but giant sandwiches so value for money is good. Appreciate that it has vegan options!

I finally got a chance to come back to this gem but this time I brought my daughter along with me. I ordered a vegan steak again because it was AMAZING and my daughter ordered a build your own turkey, bacon club. All of the staff here are so attentive and nice the sandwiches are huge no matter what size you get, they all taste really good. They have so many drink options as I mentioned before one thing I did notice but didn't get to try before was the cold salads. My daughter got a chicken salad and I got the macaroni salad, Delicious. I did not have to add anything to my salad I felt that it was seasoned well. I have to come back and try another sandwich soon!!!!

Small sandwich shoppe with an interesting menu and quick turnaround time. No one else inside on a Wednesday afternoon, so got to look over the menu to the right and place an order immediately. Various different sizes to choose from based on your hunger level. Opted for the "Mini" Devil Sandwich ($10) and a Snapple ($3?). The Devil consists of salami, mortadella, cappa, provolone, peppers, lettuce, tomato, onion, and chipotle mayo. True to its name with a good amount of spice level, and not overdoing it on the meat. Could have used more sauce, though the bread did stay crunchy overall. No place to sit down here, but they do seem to be efficient in getting your order out. Good lunch take out if in the area.

Stacked and ready to go! I would like to thank Yelp Community Manager Samantha for recommending me this sandwich spot. Wow! These sandwiches are amazing! They also come in 3 different sizes that feed 1, 1 to 2 and 3 people. I ordered the signature "Stacked OG" that feeds up to 3. The sandwich includes ham, salami, turkey, roast beef, provolone, mortadella, American cheese, and an assortment of veggies. The relishes they add to the sandwiches make them extra yummy. I watched them prepare my sandwich and when they handed it to me. I felt like I was cradling a football and had the urge to strike that quintessential Heisman trophy pose with my sandwich nestled safely against my body, out of my way while I run it in for a sandwich touchdown! The sandwich shop is called Stacked for a reason. They pile it on thick. So unless you can stretch your jaws out like a hungry python, I recommend you flatten it out with your palm or cut it into slices to give your mouth less of a workout. To find parking in the area is a nightmare. Stacked is located a few doors down by the 112th police precinct, so all the street parking in the immediate area are earmarked for the police department and authorized vehicles only. Our vehicles are not authorized, other than authorized to be towed if you park there. Park further away and walk over. They also make custom salad bowls and other yummy sandwich combinations. It's definitely work the trip if you love subs. It's a delicious sandwich that doesn't skimp on portions and made with quality provisions. I highly recommend it!